New York Red BullsNew York City FC
- 1Carlos Miguel
- 12Dylan Nealis
- 4Andres Reyes
- 3Noah Eile
- 47John Tolkin
- 2Dennis Gjengaar
- 20Felipe Carballo
- 75Daniel Edelman
- 17Cameron Harper
- 13Dante Vanzeir
- 9Lewis Morgan
- 49Matt Freese
- 24Tayvon Gray
- 13Thiago Martins Thiago Martins
- 80Justin Haak
- 22Kevin O'Toole
- 55Keaton Parks
- 6James Sands
- 8Andres Perea
- 17Hannes Wolf
- 16Alonso Martinez
- 27Maxi Moralez
